(1) Non-credible rollout; (2) credible rollout, non-credible performance; (3) credible rollout, super-credible performance; and (4) super-credible rollout with continued performance.

The following are three examples that range from “dismiss,” “credible,” and “super credible.” I will let you decide which is which:

1. A spam email promises you “top Google ranking for only $99″ a month. The email has spelling and grammatical errors and comes from a generic email service.
2. A search for “plumber” shows a company first in a local pack of search engine results.
3. A search for a marketing agency shows a company first in the PPC results with seller ratings (5 gold stars), third in the local pack with 5 gold stars, and in the organic results with review stars showing for the organic listing.

It’s fairly simple to figure out which of these businesses enter your awareness as credible, super credible or ripe for instant dismissal. This example illustrates how credibility is layered over a typical local visibility strategy.

SEO Basics

Reviews are important, but you must also take a quick pit stop to ensure the SEO “nuts and bolts” are all in place. Page titles, meta descriptions and your Google My Business page must all be completed and carefully crafted to ensure returned listings for your business look the part and deliver your message.

This is the foundation that your credibility is built upon, so be sure to get these basics 100% dialed in.

The Three Stages Of Credibility

To effectively apply the line of credibility to local search, we have to change the model a little and consider the customer journey. How do potential customers become aware of us? How credible do we look upon further investigation? What can we do to further push credibility over time and prevent a dip below the line of credibility?

We have found it useful to break your journey towards “super credibility” into these three stages:

1. Initial Awareness

How credible do you appear on a first glance? How did the prospect or customer discover you? Remember that certain strategies and/or situations may introduce your business under the line of credibility (e.g., bad reviews), which makes your first job to pop above the line.

An example of how to make your customer aware of your credibility is the star rating that appears on your paid, organic or local search results. Five or more reviews on your Google My Business page will add those all-important stars to your listing. This is critical to illustrate initial credibility and launch you into the customers conscience as a credible business.

The example below shows how effective this can be. With only one business having reviews amongst the paid, local and organic listings, this business stands out as a beacon of credibility. (Disclosure: this is my company)

In many local businesses, having reviews on your Google My Business page and in the local results will be enough, but you can go way further. If your keywords return results for business directories (e.g., Yelp, Urban Spoon, TripAdvisor, Angie’s List, etc.) then often these will allow for reviews. In certain industries, prospects will go directly to these trusted portals to locate businesses and check out reviews.

Optimizing your listings on these popular sites and (in the case of sites like TripAdvisor) actively working to ensure that you are well ranked can boost credibility. Similarly, mentions or guest content on highly credible blogs and news outlets in your space can provide a highly credible introduction to your business.

If you run paid search advertisements, then generating reviews on sites like Feefo will allow you to connect your PPC account to those seller ratings. If your competition is doing this and you are not, you may introduce your business under the line of credibility. Furthermore, if others are not yet showing reviews in their paid listings, you can generate a strategic credibility advantage.

The following example shows two advertisers: one with a very basic PPC advert and another with a more comprehensive listing using callouts, sitelinks and seller ratings. This seller’s rating of 3.7 stars is not ideal, but it still seems the more credible of the two listings due to the presence of stars; this works on an almost subconscious level.

If I were the advertiser, I would be working on that rating to take it to 4.5 and upwards — but, in principle, this is still a more credible looking advert for the presence of the reviews and other ad extensions.

As ever, the best advice and approach is tailored to your unique situation, so you must review the landscape when looking for reviews and credibility opportunities (and problems). What do the results around your big search terms look like? What are your competitors doing? How credible do they appear in the first instance? How credible do you appear? What does a brand search for your business look like?

This basic research will provide you with a roadmap for introducing your business to prospective customers as a highly credible partner.

2. Evaluation

Once a prospect is aware of your business, what comes next? Does he or she simply read a few reviews on your Google My Business page and get in touch? Or, does the customer need to see reviews, testimonials, white papers, case studies, and even check out how your company and employees engage on social media?

Both options are perfectly viable, and many variations exist in between. The key here is to understand the requirements and goals of your target audience and your current credibility within your marketplace.

For example, if you are a restaurant in a city, then where do you sit in the TripAdvisor rankings? What do your TripAdvisor reviews look like? Often, correctly assigning your restaurant to a subcategory such as “Thai” or “Indian” can create a smaller pack to compete with.

Being the number one restaurant in your location may be tough, but getting to the top three in your category is generally achievable. This moves beyond simply having good reviews on Google and a few reviews on TripAdvisor into a strategic use of these platforms for super credibility (and a trophy position to use in your marketing).

The specifics will always vary depending on your unique situation, and most if not all business categories will have specific vertical directories and portals that can be leveraged to great effect in your journey towards super credibility.

3. Credibility Over Time

It is not always going to be possible to have super credibility out of the gate, and getting to such a stature will take time. Likewise, credibility can rise or fall in any given time period and, as such, should be monitored and managed.

If you have determined that acquiring super credibility will require more than reviews and will need white papers, case studies, blog posts and PR, then getting all of these aspects in place will again take time.

Remember that Planetary Resources was created in 2009 but not announced till 2012, when they had established a team of players that enabled them to have super credibility from launch. I am not suggesting keep your business under wraps for three years — rather, I am imploring you to consider this a journey, where each further step takes you closer to becoming super credible.

This is an iterative process that is never truly finished and not something to simply tick off your list. A single new review each month may be plenty for some businesses, whilst others may need daily reviews.

The overarching point is to tailor the maintenance of your credibility to the unique needs of your business.

Building Your Own Super Credibility

As with all marketing guidance, you have to take this information and tailor it to your own specific needs, and that means designing your own credibility plan.

The first stage of this is to understand your marketplace and customers and then to understand the tools at your disposal. You can start with some simple keyword research or go a little more in depth and develop buyer personas to provide additional insight into where your priorities lie.

The Tools Of Credibility

There are many tools in the credibility toolbox, and choosing the right ones will depend upon your business and the customers you are targeting. Your market research and buyer personas will guide you here.

The following is not an exhaustive list, yet these elements will likely be the backbone of any serious credibility campaign.

1. Reviews

Reviews are really the big one for many local businesses. Some thought must be given to the location and type of reviews needed. In many cases, Google+ is a good starting point; you can then branch outwards from there.

2. Testimonials

Simple testimonials from real people can work wonders. If you can link to their social media profiles and have a nice, smiling picture along with a quote of lofty praise, then all the better. Again, consider your target customers when deciding who to use and the content of these testimonials.

3. White Papers & Ebooks

White papers and ebooks provide a solid way to demonstrate your credibility. Better still, these can be used with various other promotion tools (paid, social, organic) to help generate awareness.

4. Case Studies

A recent study by the Content Marketing Institute demonstrated that 63% of marketers believe case studies to be effective, and I feel this is somewhat conservative. Case studies can be packed with facts and figures that clearly illustrate how you have boosted profits and provided a clear return on the investment for similar customers. When it comes down to larger projects (and you are in the running with other companies), then case studies are the tool for the job.

5. Blog Posts

You don’t need to think of blogging on your own site as being purely about building masses of traffic; this form of content can provide evidence of how well you know your trade. Likewise, external posts on highly visible sites in your industry can lend credibility and build an audience. Many of the bigger SEO and digital marketing companies have a “featured in” section on their homepage showing where they blog to borrow credibility from these key industry sites.

6. Social Media

Social media can provide a window into the business and is yet another place where reviews can be gathered. More telling is how the company at a brand and employee level interact with customers, prospects and their industry as a whole. What better way to assess credibility at a granular level than to follow the boss and his team members and see what they are up to? Do you respond to questions from prospects? Are you posting embarrassing drunken messages? Arguing with customers?

Social can also be a powerful tool to seed out your case studies, testimonials, white papers, and other credibility-building content.

7. Third-Party Sites

In every industry, opportunities abound to be mentioned on external sites — from general business directories to vertical-specific directories, from location-focused websites to more typical citation sources. If these portals rank well in your industry/location, then chances are these present an opportunity to develop more positive reputation signals and to funnel more warmed up traffic from these sites.

Putting It All To Work

I have outlined some key strategies here, but in many cases, it is the intersection of these elements that work together to deliver super credibility.

For example, let’s say you have a bunch of killer case studies. You could write blog posts that summarize the main takeaways, then promote those blog posts on social media. You could develop video versions or slide presentations based on these case studies. You could mention the case studies on your main landing pages, in email signatures, in newsletters, and anywhere they might help drive awareness and convert that browser into a buyer. You want to get yourself in front of the potential customer from every angle and ensure that every interaction they have with your business or brand is a positive one.

With an SEO mindset, it can be all too easy to focus solely on ranking a few spaces higher — while forgetting that we also need to win clicks and convert those users while we have their attention. The strategies here will drive engagement with your search listings and subsequently convince those browsers that you are the man for the job.

In fact, the word around the Local SEO campfire (which is backed up by some small-scale experiments) is that engagement with local listings can have a positive impact on rank in the local pack. Further to that, the more rich, credible content you build, the more of a reason people have to talk about and link to you, and the bigger your digital fingerprint becomes — all good things.

Becoming A Credibility Super Hero

Credibility is relative. In some industries/locations, there are still very few reviews. In these situations, becoming the most credible company can be easy, and this is a better use of your time than simply focusing on moving your listing a few more positions up the local pack.

If you have one takeaway from this article, it should be to aim higher. Reputation is everything in business, so don’t just get the same 5 reviews your competitors have. Do more than you think you need to. Don’t settle for just being credible. Be more. Be super credible.